26
May
10

SB 1070 Treats Illegal Aliens Almost Like Citizens

SB 1070, the Arizona effort to control the tsunami of illegals that threaten to upend their state, has become  a lightening rod to factions within our country. Congress gave the President of Mexico a standing ovation when he condemned it (and by proxy, the nation), even though polls show a majority of Americans agree with controlling illegal immigration (up to 75% on the last one I read)

It reminds me of Charles Darwin’s Origin of Species. Another lightening rod that publicized ideas many didn’t like.

But this is the joy of a democratic nation–freedom of speech, encouragement to debate.

A group of us got together, read the Arizona Immigration bill and shared our thoughts. We forced anyone with an opinion to support it by citing the document. We didn’t allow any emotional argument (though we admit that emotion is an important ingredient in mankind’s decisions) and we ignored the ‘slippery slope’ type of conclusion–projecting what might happen based on worst-case scenarios. That’s just too subjective.

Here’s what we got (read the original SB 1070 here)–bold and italics are quotes from the bill:

  • a compelling interest in the cooperative enforcement of federal immigration laws throughout all of Arizona--we aren’t lawyers, so couldn’t draw a conclusion on the legitimacy of this. Can Arizona assist the Feds in their jobs? This seems to be a hot button issue with the talking heads.
  • Here’s one of the biggest issues discussed on the main stream media–what proof of citizenship suffices if an individual is stopped on suspicion of an illegal act? The bill includes any valid United States Federal, State or local government issued identification. This could be a library card, or a pay stub from a government job. A school ID…
  • FOR ANY LAWFUL CONTACT MADE BY A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL OR AGENCY … WHERE REASONABLE SUSPICION EXISTS THAT THE PERSON IS AN ALIEN WHO IS UNLAWFULLY PRESENT IN THE UNITED STATES, A REASONABLE ATTEMPT SHALL BE MADE, WHEN PRACTICABLE, TO DETERMINE THE IMMIGRATION STATUS OF THE PERSON. THE PERSON’S IMMIGRATION STATUS SHALL BE VERIFIED WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT PURSUANT TO 8 UNITED STATES CODE SECTION 1373(c). –sounds like Arizona will not decide on immigration status, but defer to ICE. The next few sections after this quoted portion continue with that thread–state officials will turn over anyone they discover is illegal to Federal jurisdiction for remediation
  • A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER, WITHOUT A WARRANT, MAY ARREST A PERSON IF THE OFFICER HAS PROBABLE CAUSE TO BELIEVE THAT THE PERSON HAS COMMITTED ANY PUBLIC OFFENSE THAT MAKES THE PERSON REMOVABLE FROM THE UNITED STATES.–since most crimes don’t require a warrant for an arrest for American citizens, this sounds like they are treating potentially illegal residents as citizens until proven otherwise. This is what American citizens have come to expect from one of the substantive principles of our laws– innocent until proven guilty.
  • Page 2 itemized what law enforcement officials could do once they arrested an individual suspected of being an illegal alien (arrested, only after they were suspected of a crime). Read them yourself, but they sound like the usual fact-gathering actions for any American citizen suspected of a crime
  • Trespassing by illegal aliens; assessment; exception; –interesting take on illegal aliens. None of us disagreed that illegal entrants into the state weren’t guilty of minimally ‘trespassing’. SB1070 goes on to define the repercussions of that breach of law
  • SB1070 addresses the guilt of those who smuggle aliens into the country, ramping up the ramifications when those actions include underage individuals without the presence of their parents and the use of weapons.
  • IT IS UNLAWFUL FOR A PERSON WHO IS UNLAWFULLY PRESENT IN THE UNITED STATES AND WHO IS AN UNAUTHORIZED ALIEN TO KNOWINGLY APPLY FOR WORK, SOLICIT WORK IN A PUBLIC PLACE OR PERFORM WORK AS AN EMPLOYEE OR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR IN THIS STATE. –we had different levels of agreement/disagreement on this part, based on the economic need of the hirer and the hiree, but we all agreed this part of the puzzle was critical to a comprehensive immigration law
  • This next part was interesting. The law not only addresses the responsibility of employers for providing the economic impetus to illegal immigration, but the part of those who transport them. This seemed a fair and honest effort to get to the root of the problem, rather than shuffle all responsibility off onto those who are the easiest to catch: THE PERSON IS IN VIOLATION OF A CRIMINAL OFFENSE AND IS  TRANSPORTING, MOVING, CONCEALING, HARBORING OR SHIELDING OR ATTEMPTING TO TRANSPORT, MOVE, CONCEAL, HARBOR OR SHIELD AN ALIEN IN THIS STATE IN A VEHICLE IF THE PERSON KNOWS OR RECKLESSLY DISREGARDS THE FACT THAT THE ALIEN HAS COME TO, HAS ENTERED OR REMAINS IN THE UNITED STATES IN VIOLATION OF LAW.

 

Nowhere did any of us see a goal aimed at racial profiling. SB1070 doesn’t highlight a group, rather a problem, much like the Equal Rights Amendment focused on events that fell disproportionately on particular groups.

Overall, the law seems to bestow upon illegals the rights enjoyed by American citizens when it comes to how we fare under the legal system. I don’t know if that’s good or bad, or if Americans want to do that. President Obama’s administration seems willing to require civilian trials and Miranda warnings for terrorists. The question is: Is this the direction the country is going?

In a perfect world, wouldn’t it be nice to treat our neighbors as our family. But is that realistic?

For more, read this post on how to straddle the Arizona Immigration Law fence–poorly.

Share

Advertisements

2 Responses to “SB 1070 Treats Illegal Aliens Almost Like Citizens”


  1. May 26, 2010 at 10:13 pm

    Interesting, and well-thought out. Here you say: “In a perfect world, wouldn’t it be nice to treat our neighbors as our family. But is that realistic?”, and the answer is no. In the old adage “Do unto others as they would do unto you” we should treat our neighbors as they treat us. Let’s encourage our law-breakers to cross the border. Let’s arrest and deport all who are here illegally. Let’s heavily punish employers who hire illegals. It’s only fair right?


What do you think? Leave a comment and I'll reply.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


What’s in this blog

Discover the sizzle in science. It's not that stuff that's always for the smart kids. It's the need to know. The passion for understanding. The absolute belief that for every problem, there is a solution. The creative mind seeking truth in a world of mystery. The quest for the Holy Grail.

That's science.

Read Sizzling Science on Kindle

kindle

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 232 other followers

Share This

Bookmark and Share

Categories

Documents

Books I’m Reading

Great Science Books

Assembling California
Born On A Blue Day: Inside the Extraordinary Mind of an Autistic Savant
The Forest People
Geology Underfoot in Southern California
The Land's Wild Music: Encounters with Barry Lopez, Peter Matthiessen, Terry Tempest William, and James Galvin
My Life with the Chimpanzees
Naked Earth: The New Geophysics
Our Inner Ape: A Leading Primatologist Explains Why We Are Who We Are
The Runaway Brain: The Evolution of Human Uniqueness
Sand Rivers
The Singing Neanderthals: The Origins of Music, Language, Mind, and Body
The Tree Where Man Was Born
The Wildlife of Southern Africa: A Field Guide to the Animal and Plants of the Region
The Worlds of a Maasai Warrior: An Autobiography


Jacqui's favorite books »
Share book reviews and ratings with Jacqui, and even join a book club on Goodreads.

RSS Fact and Fiction about Early Man

  • Ki'ti's Story, 75,000 BC December 11, 2016
    author: Bonnye Matthews name: Jacqui average rating: 4.25 book published: 2012 rating: 5 read at: 2016/12/11 date added: 2016/12/11 shelves: early-man review: […]
    Bonnye Matthews
  • Meeting Prehistoric Man October 4, 2014
    author: GHR von Koenigswald name: Jacqui average rating: 4.00 book published: 1492 rating: 5 read at: 2014/10/04 date added: 2014/10/04 shelves: early-man review: Meeting Prehistoric Man by GHR Von Koenigswald is a journey throughout the world in discovery of early man as paleoanthropologists understood him during VonKoenigswald's time, circa 1950' […]
    GHR von Koenigswald
  • Letters from the Field, 1925-1975 September 13, 2014
    author: Margaret Mead name: Jacqui average rating: 4.20 book published: 1977 rating: 5 read at: 2014/09/13 date added: 2014/09/13 shelves: early-man review: If you didn't read my last week's post, you may wonder why I am so excited about Margaret Mead's eye-opening book, Letters From the Field. Even if you read me last week, you may wonder--I […]
    Margaret Mead
  • The Unfolding of Language: An Evolutionary Tour of Mankind's Greatest Invention January 12, 2014
    author: Guy Deutscher name: Jacqui average rating: 4.16 book published: 2005 rating: 3 read at: date added: 2014/01/12 shelves: early-man, research review: Dr. Deutscher has done a scholarly, thorough discussion on the roots of language, but I believe he started too late in time. I'm of the persuasion that language involves more than the spoken word. I […]
    Guy Deutscher
  • She Who remembers November 3, 2013
    author: Linda Lay Shuler name: Jacqui average rating: 4.12 book published: 1988 rating: 4 read at: date added: 2013/11/03 shelves: early-man review: […]
    Linda Lay Shuler
  • The Runaway Brain: The Evolution Of Human Uniqueness July 25, 2011
    author: Christopher Wills name: Jacqui average rating: 4.12 book published: 1993 rating: 5 read at: date added: 2011/07/24 shelves: science, early-man review: In my lifelong effort to understand what makes us human, I long ago arrived at the lynchpin to that discussion: our brain. Even though bipedalism preceded big brains, and we couldn't be who we are […]
    Christopher Wills
  • The Origin Of Humankind (Science Masters Series) July 25, 2011
    author: Richard E. Leakey name: Jacqui average rating: 3.96 book published: 1981 rating: 5 read at: date added: 2011/07/24 shelves: early-man, history review: If you're interested in man's roots, there are several authors you must read: Birute Galdikas Dian Fosse Donald Johanson GHR Von Koenigsman Glen Isaacs Jared Diamond Ian Tattersell Lev Vygots […]
    Richard E. Leakey
  • Lucy: The Beginnings of Humankind July 24, 2011
    author: Donald C. Johanson name: Jacqui average rating: 4.11 book published: 1981 rating: 5 read at: date added: 2011/07/24 shelves: early-man, science review: I read this book when I was writing a paleo-historic drama of the life of earliest man. My characters were Homo habilines, but they cohabited Africa with Australopithecines, so to understand the co-st […]
    Donald C. Johanson
  • Through a Window: My Thirty Years with the Chimpanzees of Gombe July 24, 2011
    author: Jane Goodall name: Jacqui average rating: 4.25 book published: 1990 rating: 5 read at: date added: 2011/07/24 shelves: early-man, science review: I have read every book that Jane Goodall wrote. She has an easy-going writing style that shares scientific principals easily with the layman. Probably because when she started, she was little more than a no […]
    Jane Goodall
  • In the Shadow of Man July 24, 2011
    author: Jane Goodall name: Jacqui average rating: 4.33 book published: 1971 rating: 5 read at: date added: 2011/07/23 shelves: early-man, science review: I read Jane Goodall's In the Shadow of Man (Houghton Mifflin 1971) years ago as research for a paleo-historic novel I was writing. I needed background on the great apes so I could show them acting appr […]
    Jane Goodall
California Yellow Pages
blogarama - the blog directory
Free Blog Directory
wordpress stats
blog search directory
Science Blogs

Vote for Me


%d bloggers like this: